Rose or Martha

[TenRoseLove]

Who did you like better Rose or matha? For me it's Rose all the way :D
Please vote in the poll!

[N4H]

That question was easier to answer last year. Now we have Donna, and now I have no real preference. I could click all 3 (if Donna was an option), none, either, or even a completely new companion if that was an option. Basically, whatever they choose to offer up I'm open to the experience.

[Bored of the Dead]

My choice is Donna.

By far the best of the lot.

An absolutely wonderful character. Lights up the screen every time she is on.

[edb]

Out of those two it has to be Rose, seeing as though your question was Rose or Martha? ;) Rose always had more about her than Martha, not that Martha was a bad companion at all, they both have/had really good qualities, I just preferred Rose. :)

But like BotD, I've got to say that Donna has become my favourite companion so far. :D

[N4H]

Well, if we we can choose outside the list of 2, much as I like Donna I'll go bring back Romana and K9...

After that I'd go Doctor's Daughter, or Sally Sparrow. I'd like a new-but-seen-before companion other than Rose or Martha. Their stories feel sufficiently told. I think Donna has more power as a one season companion. It's like the Rocky movies. I kind of enjoy them all, but the classic that was the original Rocky would have had more power than all of them as a group if it could have stood by itself.